Current IntelPower LibraryShop main store

Selection guide

Setting overload relays for high-inertia motor starts

Motors and motor starters Published 8 min read

Short answer

Set the current dial at the motor's nameplate full-load current and buy starting time with the trip class, not with a higher setting: Class 10 holds starts up to about 7 s at 600 percent, Class 20 to about 14 s, Class 30 to about 21 s. Longer starts need reduced-current starting, not a bigger relay.

On this page
  1. Why does the overload trip before a high-inertia motor reaches speed?
  2. What do Class 10, Class 20 and Class 30 actually mean?
  3. Where do I set the current dial on the overload relay?
  4. Which trip class matches my motor's acceleration time?
  5. How do I measure acceleration time and starting current?
  6. How does the class choice work on a real fan start?
  7. When is raising the current dial the wrong fix?
  8. What if the start outlasts Class 30?
  9. Questions asked

Set the overload dial at the motor's nameplate full-load current, and buy the seconds of a long start with the trip class: Class 10 covers accelerations up to about 7 s at 600 percent of the setting, Class 20 up to 14 s, Class 30 up to 21 s. Starts longer than that call for reduced-current starting, not a slower relay or a raised dial. Crushers, ball mills, large fans, centrifuges and loaded conveyors accelerate slowly enough to outlast a Class 10 curve, and the relay that trips on every start is usually the right current setting on the wrong class. This is how to read the classes, measure the start, and pick.

Why does the overload trip before a high-inertia motor reaches speed? #

Because the start lasts longer than the relay's curve allows: a Class 10 overload must trip within 10 seconds at 600 percent of its setting, and a loaded crusher, fan or centrifuge can draw near that current for longer than that. The relay is matching its curve, not protecting wrongly.

High-inertia loads keep the rotor accelerating for many seconds, and the motor draws near locked-rotor current for that whole period. An overload relay cannot tell a long normal start from a stalled motor except by how long it is willing to wait, and that waiting time is the trip class. Do not confuse two different dropouts here: the overload's thermal trip opens after seconds of acceleration current, while the branch breaker's instantaneous element operates in the first cycles at a much higher current. If the magnetic element is what is dropping out, that is troubleshooting intermittent instantaneous motor start trips, not a class problem.

What do Class 10, Class 20 and Class 30 actually mean? #

The class number is the relay's maximum trip time in seconds at a fixed multiple of its setting: 10, 20 and 30 seconds at 600 percent of the dial on NEMA-style data, and the same class numbers as maxima at 7.2 times the setting under IEC 60947-4-1 test conditions.

IEC 60947-4-1, the low-voltage switchgear and controlgear standard covering contactors and motor starters including overload relays, lists the standard tripping classes as 10A, 10, 20 and 30, and defines the class as the maximum tripping time in seconds at 7.2 times the relay's current setting, tested from cold under the standard's specified conditions. The band inside a class is real: a class 10 electronic device is specified to trip after more than 5 s and within 10 s at that multiple. NEMA-style curves are quoted at 600 percent of the relay rating, where Class 10 trips in 10 s or less and Class 20 in roughly 20. The different test multiple matters less than the habit it supports: treat the class number as the seconds you can spend at about six times the dial.

Where do I set the current dial on the overload relay? #

At the motor's nameplate full-load current, not a percentage above it. The dial's job is running overload protection, and the trip class is what buys the extra seconds of a long start.

On a bimetal or eutectic relay that is the dial itself; on an electronic relay it is the current-setting parameter in the relay's menu. The basis is the same whatever the duty, which is the same first step as in selecting overload and jam protection for a reversible motor. NFPA 70, the National Electrical Code, 2023 edition, covers motor circuits and their overload protection in Article 430; editions and local amendments differ, so confirm the requirement that applies to your installation with the authority having jurisdiction and the equipment documentation. Nothing about a long start moves the dial: acceleration is the class's problem, not the setting's.

Which trip class matches my motor's acceleration time? #

Match the class to the measured acceleration time with about 30 percent headroom: Class 10 for starts up to 7 seconds, Class 20 up to 14 seconds, Class 30 up to 21 seconds, and beyond that cut the starting current instead of hunting for a slower relay.

The headroom exists because class times are cold-start maxima, and a warm relay or a second start trips earlier. Documented selection guidance sets the first boundary: the CEP7 solid-state overload manual moves loads with acceleration longer than 7 seconds to a Class 15 or Class 20 curve, and to Class 30 only in rare cases. Carrying the same margin up the scale gives this table.

Measured acceleration time Trip class to select Class maximum at about 6x the dial Headroom at band limit
Up to 7 s Class 10 10 s 3 s
7 to 14 s Class 20 about 20 s 6 s
14 to 21 s Class 30 30 s 9 s
Over 21 s none; reduce starting current 30 s is the standard top class n/a

Some electronic relays offer an intermediate curve such as Class 15 between 10 and 20; use one when a start lands awkwardly on a band edge, per that relay's documentation.

How do I measure acceleration time and starting current? #

Time the start with a recording meter and read the current at the same time: a power-quality meter or a clamp meter with inrush capture gives the two numbers that pick the class, which are seconds from contactor close to current settling, and the current as a multiple of the dial.

Record current against time from the instant the contactor closes until the trace flattens at running current; the length of the plateau is the acceleration time. Clamping around insulated conductors keeps you outside the enclosure, but the moment the job means opening the starter door to check a dial or a wire, lock out, de-energize, and test for absence of voltage before the cover comes off. Run the start twice and use the longer of the two times, because a warm motor and a warm relay both work against you on the second attempt. Keep repeated starts inside the starts-per-hour figure on the motor data sheet rather than a rule of thumb. A drive already in the circuit can log the same curve from its own trend.

How does the class choice work on a real fan start? #

A 75 hp fan on a 460 V starter with a 96 A dial and a 12-second, 5.8x start takes Class 20: 12 seconds beats the Class 10 maximum of 10 seconds, and Class 20 holds 20 seconds with 8 to spare.

Illustrative example, with every input stated:

  • Motor: 75 hp, 460 V, three phase, nameplate full-load current 96 A
  • Load: centrifugal fan, high inertia
  • Dial: 96 A, set at nameplate FLC
  • Measured acceleration time: 12 s
  • Measured current during acceleration: 5.8 x FLC

The arithmetic:

  • Start current = 5.8 x 96 A = 556.8 A, about 557 A
  • As a multiple of the dial: 557 A / 96 A = 5.8, that is 580 percent, just under the 600 percent point at which class times are quoted, so the class maximum applies with a little time to spare
  • Class 10: maximum 10 s, and 12 s is 2 s past it, so the relay opens before the fan reaches speed
  • Class 20: maximum about 20 s, headroom = 20 s minus 12 s = 8 s, which is 40 percent of the class time, above the 30 percent line
  • Decision: Class 20, dial stays at 96 A

The same fan with a heavier load path measuring 16 s would leave only 4 s of Class 20 headroom, 20 percent, under the line, and the choice moves to Class 30.

When is raising the current dial the wrong fix? #

Whenever the trip happens during acceleration: raising the dial to survive a start slows the relay at every current level, and a motor can overheat badly without the overload ever tripping, which is a documented failure pattern, not a theory. The mechanism is laid out in why motors burn up with no overload trips on 480 V.

Work the checks in order before touching the dial:

  1. Dial against nameplate full-load current.
  2. Trip class against the measured acceleration time.
  3. Running current against the nameplate after a completed start, because a genuine overload shows up here.
  4. Mechanical causes: crusher standing full, brake not releasing, bearing seizure, a load that has changed.

Remember that an overload relay sees current only, and there are heating modes it cannot see at all; the boundaries are covered in what current-only motor protection can and cannot detect.

What if the start outlasts Class 30? #

Change the start, not the relay: standard classes stop at 30 seconds at 600 percent, so an acceleration beyond about 21 seconds needs lower starting current, meaning a soft starter or a drive, reduced-voltage starting, or a motor with more starting torque and thermal reserve.

Before declaring the load too inertial, rule out the mechanical list above, because a crusher that starts empty and stalls loaded is telling you about the material, not the inertia. A soft starter ramps the voltage so acceleration happens at reduced current, and where the unit has its own motor-protection model, the relay arrangement follows that unit's documentation. A variable frequency drive accelerates the motor at current near full load with its electronic motor thermal protection programmed to nameplate FLC, so trip class stops being the constraint. Reduced-voltage schemes such as star-delta cut the current the relay sees, which moves the start down the curve where trip times are longer. Whichever route you take, any overload element that remains still gets the nameplate full-load current and the shortest class the new acceleration time allows.

Questions asked

Can I just fit Class 30 everywhere to stop nuisance trips?

You can, but you pay for it every time the motor stalls. The class is also the time a jam is allowed to draw locked-rotor current before the relay clears it, so Class 30 waits up to 30 seconds where Class 10 waits 10. Pick the fastest class whose band covers your measured acceleration time with headroom, and reserve Class 30 for starts that genuinely need it.

Is it acceptable to set the overload above full-load current on a long-start motor?

Not as the cure for tripping on acceleration. The dial belongs at nameplate full-load current, and the trip class is the documented way to carry a long start. Raising the dial slows the relay at every current level, including the running overloads it exists to catch, and overheating from an oversized dial shows up as insulation damage, not as a trip.

Why does the same motor trip the overload on the second start but not the first?

Because the published trip times are cold-start maxima. A bimetal or electronic relay that just carried one acceleration starts the next one from partway up its thermal curve, so it trips earlier on the same current. Space starts according to the starts-per-hour figure on the motor data sheet, and size the class for the warm start, not the lucky cold one.

Does a variable frequency drive still need a trip-class decision?

Not in the same form. A drive accelerates the motor at current near full load instead of six times it, and its built-in electronic motor thermal protection, still programmed to nameplate full-load current, takes over the overload job, so trip class stops being the constraint. The class decision returns where the motor still starts across the line: direct-on-line starters, and soft starters that ramp and then close a bypass.

Keep reading

  • Selection guide

    Selecting overload and jam protection for a reversible motor

    Set a bimetallic or electronic overload relay from the motor's nameplate full-load current — never from wattage — and give the electronic-clutch trip to a separate current-sensing jam or shock relay set above the highest normal process current. Its adjustable reset delay must outlast the cycle timer's worst-case command drop-out, and auto reset needs a deliberate-restart decision because a live run command restarts the motor.

    Motors and motor starters

  • How-to

    Wiring a three-phase coolant pump starter from a 120 V signal

    Run the machine's 120 V coolant output through the overload relay's normally closed contact to a contactor with a 120 VAC coil, and set the overload dial to the pump's nameplate full-load current — 1.8 A on a typical 1/2 HP three-phase pump, inside a 1.3–2.1 A adjustable range. Then bump-test rotation and swap any two motor leads if the pump runs backward.

    Motors and motor starters

  • Troubleshooting

    Troubleshooting intermittent instantaneous motor start trips

    An intermittent instantaneous trip on motor start is usually the random closing angle of the contactor, not a failing motor. A first peak can reach about 2.8 times the symmetrical locked-rotor current, so only starts that close near a voltage zero hit magnetic pickup. Capture all three phase currents, rank contactor pole, winding, rotor and breaker causes, and let the trip follow the part you roll.

    Motors and motor starters