Current IntelPower LibraryShop main store

Comparison

Switchgear vs MCC: what each term actually means

Power distribution and transformers Published 7 min read

Short answer

The terms mark different equipment: a low-voltage MCC is a UL 845 assembly of stab-in buckets — motor controllers to NEMA size 4, 100 hp at 460 V, feeder frames to 250 A — while switchgear is UL 1558/ANSI C37 distribution gear. A 5.5 kV metal-clad lineup with starters in its draw-out breaker compartments is switchgear with integrated motor control; document it that way.

On this page
  1. Is an MCC the same thing as switchgear?
  2. What standard is each lineup built to?
  3. How big a motor fits in an MCC bucket?
  4. Why does the drawing say switchgear but the manual say MCC?
  5. What should you call the lineup in your documents?
  6. When do you buy switchgear instead of an MCC?
  7. What are the IEC equivalents of switchgear and MCC?
  8. Questions asked

A 5.5 kV metal-clad lineup is switchgear with integrated motor-control functions — not an MCC, even when the manual calls it one. At low voltage the two words mark different equipment categories with different listings and different construction: an MCC is a manufactured assembly of motor starters and feeder breakers built from removable buckets, while switchgear is distribution gear whose breakers are not required to be removable at all. At medium voltage the categories merge, because metal-clad gear already gives every circuit a draw-out compartment and a separate medium-voltage MCC rarely pays for itself. Settle the wording on the nameplate and the compartment schedule, then document the lineup under its listed classification with the starters noted as integrated functions.

Is an MCC the same thing as switchgear? #

No. An MCC is a manufactured assembly of motor starters and feeder breakers in a standardized structure, listed to UL 845; switchgear is power-distribution equipment — at low voltage, metal-enclosed gear listed to UL 1558 and built to the ANSI C37 requirements.

The MCC exists to start and feed motors: one horizontal bus feeds vertical sections, each holding removable units. Switchgear exists to move power: incoming, tie and feeder breakers, and at low voltage it normally carries no motor control. In North American practice the word switchgear means gear meeting the ANSI C37 requirements; the less robust free-standing low-voltage distribution assemblies are switchboards, a third category that is neither of the other two.

The construction differences follow from the job:

Characteristic Low-voltage MCC Low-voltage switchgear 5.5 kV metal-clad switchgear
Primary job Motor starters and feeder breakers Power distribution Distribution plus integrated motor starting
Listing or basis UL 845 UL 1558, breakers per UL 1066 IEEE C37 metal-clad construction
How a circuit comes out Stab-in bucket into the vertical bus Draw-out power breaker, no stab-in bucket Draw-out breaker compartment, can carry starter elements
Motor controllers Up to NEMA size 4, 100 hp at 460 V, in buckets Not typical at low voltage Starter elements added in draw-out compartments
Feeder breakers Bucket frames up to 250 A Distribution-class breakers Distribution-class breakers
Bus withstand basis Three-cycle rating under UL 845 ANSI C37 ratings IEEE C37 ratings

Each bucket controller is a contactor with overload protection; if a circuit needs the full starter or only a contactor, settle that with motor starter vs contactor before the schedule goes out.

What standard is each lineup built to? #

MCCs list to UL 845 (edition 6, dated 2021), which covers complete motor-control-center assemblies for circuits with available short-circuit current up to 200,000 A rms symmetrical; low-voltage switchgear lists to UL 1558, with its power circuit breakers covered by UL 1066.

UL 845, the Standard for Motor Control Centers, covers the complete assembly — enclosure, sections and bus as one listed lineup — and sets criteria for wiring and for spacing between components. Its bus short-circuit withstand requirement is on a three-cycle basis only, which matters when you coordinate upstream devices selectively (below). UL 1558 is the Standard for Metal-Enclosed Low-Voltage Power Circuit Breaker Switchgear, and UL 1066 covers the low-voltage AC and DC power circuit breakers used in those enclosures. Confirm the listing, the marked ratings and the edition in force against the nameplate, the manufacturer's documentation and the authority having jurisdiction for the installation — local amendments move these requirements.

How big a motor fits in an MCC bucket? #

Stab-in buckets in this construction hold motor controllers up to NEMA size 4 — 100 hp at 460 V — and feeder breakers up to 250 A frames; above those sizes the circuit moves out of the standard bucket scheme.

The bucket stabs onto the vertical bus so a failed controller swaps quickly without dismantling the structure, and feeder breakers ride the same construction to the 250 A frame limit. Worked example with illustrative inputs: a 460 V, three-phase lineup with three motors to place. Full-load currents come from Table 430.250 of NFPA 70, the National Electrical Code, 2023 edition, which gives the typical full-load currents of three-phase AC motors used for branch-circuit sizing: 50 hp = 65 A, 100 hp = 124 A, 125 hp = 156 A.

  • 50 hp, 65 A: standard bucket, well inside the ceiling.
  • 100 hp, 124 A: standard bucket, exactly at the NEMA size 4 ceiling — the largest motor that stabs in.
  • 125 hp, 156 A: no bucket at this construction limit. Feed it from a 250 A frame feeder bucket to a separately mounted starter: 156 A ÷ 250 A = 0.62, so the frame carries 62 % of its rating and the starter lives outside the stab-in scheme.

Treat the placement as an estimate to check against the governing code edition and the controller documentation before the order is placed. And note: a bucket stabs onto bus that can be energized from the line side of the structure, so open and lock out the supply, then test for absence of voltage at the stabs before pulling any unit — the stab connection is not an isolating device.

Why does the drawing say switchgear but the manual say MCC? #

Because at 5.5 kV the functions merge: metal-clad switchgear already gives every circuit a draw-out breaker compartment, so the elements needed to perform the starter function go into those compartments instead of into a separate medium-voltage MCC.

The economics drive it. Medium-voltage metal-clad gear is expensive, the draw-out breaker is already most of what a bucket is, and a plant usually has relatively few medium-voltage motors — so a dedicated medium-voltage MCC rarely justifies itself. The manual's "MCC" is naming the motor-control functions in those compartments, not a separately classified assembly sitting inside the lineup; never infer a separate MCC bucket from the abbreviation alone. Metal-clad is also a specific construction class within the metal-enclosed family under the IEEE C37 standards, and the metal-clad versus metal-enclosed switchgear comparison lays out what that class demands.

What should you call the lineup in your documents? #

Call the 5.5 kV lineup switchgear with integrated motor control, and record each starter as a draw-out breaker compartment on the compartment schedule — not as a separately classified MCC bucket.

  1. Read the assembly nameplate and classification markings; the manufacturer's listing decides the category, not the habit of the drawing set.
  2. Mark the one-line diagram and the compartment schedule: which compartments are incoming and feeder breakers, which carry starter elements.
  3. Check whether the manual uses "MCC" for the whole lineup or only for the motor-control sections.
  4. Write the reconciliation into the document set once, so maintenance records and arc-flash studies inherit a single name.

The decision for this case: title the lineup switchgear, note integrated motor control on the compartments that start motors, and keep "MCC" out of the equipment-category fields unless a nameplate shows a separately classified MCC.

When do you buy switchgear instead of an MCC? #

Buy switchgear when the lineup's job is distributing power — incoming, tie and large feeder breakers with high interrupting duty and selective coordination; buy an MCC when the lineup's job is starting and feeding motors.

The three-cycle bus withstand in UL 845 is the deciding number on coordination: if upstream devices are coordinated to take longer than three cycles to clear, specify the MCC with a higher withstand rating or put those circuits in switchgear. Simple feeder distribution at lighter duty can go in a switchboard instead. Most MCCs also carry more than starters: drive buckets bring their own line- and motor-side decisions, starting with choosing a line reactor or motor reactor for a VFD, and a fieldbus routed through the structure needs the discipline covered in installing a robust PROFIBUS DP network inside an MCC.

What are the IEC equivalents of switchgear and MCC? #

IEC practice builds both from type-tested assemblies under IEC 61439, where a Form 4 draw-out MCC delivers the unit-by-unit removability that stab-in buckets give you under UL 845, and the distribution-versus-motor-control split survives intact.

The vocabulary differs — assemblies are verified by type test rather than listed, and the forms grade internal separation — but a Form 4 draw-out lineup is the thing to write into a specification when you want bucket-level serviceability on an IEC site. If the project buys at IEC voltage levels, sourcing IEC type-tested Form 4 draw-out MCCs covers what to demand from the type-test dossier.

Questions asked

Is a UL 508A control panel an acceptable substitute for an MCC?

No, they are different listings. UL 508A covers industrial control panels; UL 845 covers the complete motor control center — the structural enclosure, the sections and the bus system as one listed assembly. A group of field-built panels does not carry an MCC's bus construction or its bus withstand testing. For a lineup of starters sharing one horizontal bus, buy the UL 845 assembly.

What does the three-cycle bus withstand mean for selective coordination?

UL 845 requires a short-circuit withstand rating on the MCC bus for only three cycles. If your upstream devices are selectively coordinated and take longer than three cycles to clear a fault, the bus sees stress beyond the tested basis, so specify the MCC with a higher withstand rating. The available fault current at the line side must also stay within the assembly's marked rating; UL 845's scope runs to 200,000 A rms symmetrical.

Can I feed a load bigger than 250 A frames out of MCC buckets?

Not with this stab-in construction: feeder-breaker buckets in the scheme run to 250 A frames. A 460 V motor beyond the 100 hp bucket ceiling (a 100 hp motor draws 124 A full-load per Table 430.250 of the NEC) gets fed from a 250 A feeder bucket to a separately mounted starter, or the circuit moves into switchgear or a switchboard section.

Is a switchboard the same thing as low-voltage switchgear?

No. Both are free-standing distribution equipment, but the switchgear category is gear built to the ANSI C37 requirements and listed to UL 1558; the less robust free-standing low-voltage distribution assemblies are switchboards. In practice on a 480 V system: main-tie-main and high-fault feeders belong in switchgear, simple feeder distribution can go in a switchboard, and motor loads belong in the MCC.

Keep reading

  • Explainer

    Motor starter vs contactor: using a starter as one

    A motor starter is a contactor with an overload relay added: the relay's normally closed contact opens the coil circuit on sustained overcurrent. A starter works wherever a contactor is called for, provided three checks pass — horsepower rating at the supply voltage, coil voltage, and the overload setting against the motor's nameplate full-load current. A NEMA Size 1 covers a 3 HP motor.

    Motors and motor starters

  • How-to

    Installing a robust PROFIBUS DP network inside an MCC

    Run the bus at or below 1.5 Mbit/s, keep the cable against the bonded backplane, clamp the shield to bonded metalwork at every MCC entry, and terminate only the two electrical ends of the segment: a slower rate widens timing margins but cannot fix poor bonding or missing termination.

    Wiring, grounding and bonding

  • How-to

    Fixing voltage drop on a long 277 V lighting feeder

    The drop budget on this feeder limits the loop to 0.40 Ω — 0.267 Ω per conductor — so size up the copper or split the load across the three phases of the wye system, which relaxes the limit sixfold. Raise the source only after the two-endpoint check, because a fixed boost that fixes full-load voltage also overvoltages the panel at light load.

    Power distribution and transformers